ESGM Live

← All news

Opinion

Homosexuality & African Societies (Swaziland)

10 min read By Melusi Simelane

To better understand what young Swazis know about homosexuality, I undertook a short survey at UNISWA to determine their knowledge levels and attitudes. In particular, I wanted to learn

how open youth are to homosexuality as a sexual orientation in their society. I also examined how Christianity, as interpreted by the church in Swaziland, influences their views. The overall objective was to answer the question: how much

do the youth know about homosexuality, considering their religious and political affiliations? As a country, we have not criminalised homosexuality; however, ‘sodomy’ is a crime for all Swazis. In effect, this aspect of relationships between homosexual men has been highlighted, leading to a narrow understanding of homosexuality and much stigmatisation. I wanted to understand how common anti-gay feelings in Swaziland are, whether they are influenced by religion or the law, and how well informed people are. Interestingly, only 29% of respondents had knowingly met a gay man.

Map of Eswatini in rainbow colours with the shield from the national flag

I wanted to understand how common anti-gay feelings in Swaziland are, whether they are influenced by religion or the law, and how well informed people are. Interestingly, only 29% of respondents had knowingly met a gay man.

‘Homosexuality has no word in siSwati’; this has been used by the Prime Minister to argue that homosexuality does not exist in traditional Swazi society. However, there are a growing number of civil society organisations emerging in the homosexual community across the country to increase their visibility, improve their access to health services and help challenge stigma and discrimination towards gay men. This means living in fear, compromising their lifestyle, and being unable to practise their freedoms fully, including expression, association, and other fundamental rights.

Attitudes towards homosexuality across the world are polarising. In Europe, America, Oceania, parts of Asia and Latin America, more and more countries are legislating for equal rights of all men and women irrespective of their sexual orientation, with the churches of those countries also embracing the gay community into their fold.

However, what we are seeing in Africa is worrying. Nigeria, Zambia, Malawi, and Uganda are some of the countries which are taking a negative stand against homosexuality, arguing it is against traditional cultural values and against the teachings of the Christian church. Nigeria put into law a bill that prohibits homosexual partnerships, and Uganda has criminalised homosexuality, making it an offence to practise homosexuality or not report it.

Uganda has also prohibited civil society organisations from addressing homosexuality; in short, it is a crime to speak about homosexuality in Uganda. As a result, gay men and women live in fear; they are unable to speak openly about their homosexuality and are marginalised in mainstream society.

Homosexuality is sometimes defined in terms of an attraction, preference, orientation, or identity. The term “orientation” is particularly favoured by those who are promoting public acceptance of homosexuality. A common argument is that an inclination to homosexuality is inborn and immutable. For example, the neuroscientist and homosexual (Simon Levay) stated: “…people who think that gays and lesbians are born that way are also more likely to support gay rights”. This perspective respects the equal rights of gay men and women.

In Africa, there is a vocal school of thought that views homosexuality as a demon, stating that because God made it unequivocal in the Quran that he condemns it, it is the doing of the devil that some people are homosexual. As part of my research, I explored students’ attitudes to see if they believe it is a sin to be homosexual. Views on this diverged, with many arguing that, ‘be it Allah or God, both these heavenly beings condemn homosexuality’, whilst others said they thought it was not a sin because it is who they are; God created all lives and ‘it is not a part of the ten commandments, so I fail to understand how it can be a sin against God’.

One mentioned an interesting fact: ‘men in the B.C. times were very feminine, and they wore robes and kept long hair’. For instance, Samson kept his long hair and braided it as a sign of being God-ordained; in today’s Swazi society, this would be seen as a sign of homosexuality. Probing more deeply, I tried to learn why some students strongly felt that God condemns homosexuality. ‘God, because the scripture is explicit on the matter’ (Leviticus 18:22) – “You shall not lie with a male as one lies with a female; it is an abomination.” However, this is referring to sodomy rather than homosexuality. There do not appear to be any references to homosexuality in the Bible at all.

Whilst a majority of respondents believed homosexuality to be a sin, interestingly 35% did not; they argued that God had created all people, including homosexuals, so he could not condemn them. The question was backed by the scripture which says ‘all that is, is the creation of God’. It would appear that the students’ attitudes towards the question of whether homosexuality is a sin or not are heavily influenced by religious teachers, and their preachers’ interpretation of the Bible, with some focusing on the Bible’s message of love and acceptance ofGod’sGod’s creatures, whilst others focus on Old Testament values of condemnation and judgement.

Based on the research, it was clear that some churches are preaching hatred towards gay men, focussing exclusively on sodomy, rather than seeing gay men as human beings within society. This hatred spread by some churches is colouring people’s judgement and breeding homophobia. As a result of this, homophobia has gained momentum in Swaziland. The church should be encouraged to preach love and respect to all people irrespective of their sexuality, even though it probably needs to be sensitised; homosexuality really is broadening the current perspective, which focuses on a sexual act, which is not the heart of being homosexual.

A second focus of my research was to learn how much the students were accepting of homosexuality. I asked if they would be comfortable with society knowing their sexuality if they were to realise they were homosexual. 50% would not want other people to know if they were gay; some because of the fear of stigmatisation, and others because their own homophobia would not allow them to consider such a possibility as being gay.

However, 35% answered openly to this question, saying that for the people we live with to respect and be comfortable with who we are, we should let them know who we are first. It was my finding that a certain portion felt the issue of homosexuality should be met with acceptance, not being afraid to say who we are and what we are. Of course, some felt indifferent, 15%, saying that kind of question was uncalled for and not relevant.

After much deeper research into the issue of homosexuality and African societies, it is my finding that, indeed, the societies we live in are ill-informed about homosexuality. There is a widespread belief that homosexuality is non-African, arguing that it came with white men to insult African culture.

On the contrary, in African history, it is said that homosexuality was practised and accepted in the pre-colonial era. “When a war broke out, they took their boys with them. . . . If another man had relations with his boy, the husband could sue the interloper in court for adultery.” (English anthropologist E. E. Evans-Pritchard). This, in so far as it does not fully represent homosexuality, is evidence that it did exist.

The South African Tsonga provide another particularly well-documented instance of a boy-wife role. Several southern and western African societies also had female husbands, though whether these husbands had sexual relations with their wives is unclear in what has been written. (It seems that anthropologists studying the phenomenon did not ask that question.)

With reports from hundreds of sub-Saharan African locales of male-male sexual relations and from about fifty of female-female sexual relations, it is clear that same-sex sexual relations existed in traditional African societies, though varying in forms and in the degree of public acceptance. Much of this same-sex activity was situational or premarital, though there were long-term relationships, too. The special Christian animus toward homosexuality was carried to Africa by Europeans and stimulated denials that “the sin not named among Christians” existed among “unspoiled” Africans.

This is supposed to be an eye-opener because, as much as it is easy to believe that homosexuality is non-African, it is not true. The only non-African thing is homophobia, which ‘came with the white men during the colonial era, in the form of religious doctrines’ (Donna Smith, head of Forum for the Empowerment of Women). The belief of many Africans that homosexuality is exogenous to the history of their people is a belief with real social consequences–in particular, the stigmatisation of their people who engage in homosexual behaviour. As a result, many times we have had reports of homosexuals being victimisevictimised of physical abuse.

Confusing enough is that a little over two years ago, the United Kingdom legalised same-sex marriage, and we still decided to interpret the Bible in a way that is oppressive to humanity. Many churches around the world interpret the Bible in different ways.

The Archbishop of Canterbury was quoted in a recent BBC report saying, ‘it would be very dangerous for the Christians in Africa if the church were to endorse the newly enacted legal document allowing same-sex marriages’; he went on to say that was not to mean that they overlooked the human rights of those at home(inside the UK). He said he received calls from different religious figures in Africa urging him not to endorse the law, as it would mean they could not accept aid. This is a clear indication of the double standards we have as Africans. Regardless of our own heritage being democratic enough, we still want to interpret biblical teachings in a way that tends to undermine human rights.

While undertaking my research on this paper I came across some writing by Azad Essa, an Aljazeera News Agency reporter, titled ‘homophobia; Africa’s new apartheid’. He explained how homophobia is ruling the African continent and how societies invested in religion and tradition have oppressed the homosexuals who live in fear each and every day. I found this true, from the hate I received while responding to the questionnaire. Most men, and at times women, would threaten me, showing just how much they felt threatened by homosexuality.

I therefore had to ask whether homosexuality was a threat and what impact it had on national stability. 65% of the questionnaire respondents felt it had the gravest negative impact on the citizenry, and for that reason it was a great threat to them. I gathered that the populace was being influenced to do this ‘unholy’ act. The general ideology was that without anything being said about homosexuality, no one would want to associate themselves with such an unnatural act. This means that people should hide their identity. Some said it encourages all sorts of immorality, arguing that condoning one immorality licences the whole society to practise immorality.

However, the remaining 35% said it had no impact whatsoever, stating that these are citizens contributing to society economically like all others, so they should not be reduced to the measure of their impact.

In conclusion, it is my finding that homosexuality is mistaken for promiscuity and immoral sexual behaviour. And therefore it behoves us to stand up and give out the relevant information about homosexuality. This would help get people to understand it better. Such misconceptions as those that homosexuality is all about people having ‘unholy’ sex are the reasons no one respects homosexuals in Swaziland.

It is time people got to understand homosexuality as what it is: an enduring pattern of or disposition to experience sexual, affectionate, or romantic attractions, primarily or exclusively to people of the same sex. It also refers to an individual’s personal and social identity based on those attractions, the behaviours that express them, and membership in a community of others who share them. It is not just about sex; it is life, and it is who a person is.

First published on LGBTI Swaziland on 11 February 2017.

Media enquiries info@eswatiniminorities.org